Hello and welcome to the forum. Thank you for the question. What were your other numbers? The Total Cholesterol number is number that is comprised of your LDL (bad) cholesterol and your HDL (good) cholesterol. Altering either of those two components and you can change your Total number. LDL is changed typically through diet while HDL is related to exercise. You can increase your HDL (the higher the number, the better) by daily exercise (if your doctor has cleared you for exercise). Some people do not respond to their own measures to control cholesterol and they will need to take medication to control it. At this point, you are elevated but not far from the goal of under 200. Here's a guide to cholesterol. https://www.webmd.com/cholesterol-management/guide/understanding-numbers
In regards to peanut butter, while it is high in fat often, it is the 'good' kind of fat that we need. Here is some information regarding peanut butter https://www.healthline.com/health/high-cholesterol/peanut-butter-cholesterol#peanut-butter-and-cholesterol. The American Heart Association deems peanut butter healthy for your heart. This should not be impacting you negatively in terms of your cholesterol numbers.
Please let us know what else we can help you with. Would you like ideas of how to naturally decrease cholesterol?