Aa
A
A
A
Close
Depression Community
10.5k Members
973741 tn?1342346373

Diagnosis Depression What to Ask your Doctor

Being diagnosed with depression is a process. Every person is different but in order to have a clinical diagnosis, you have to meet the criteria.  What kinds of questions do you ask your doctor?

This article is really helpful for this topic. https://www.webmd.com/depression/12-questions-ask-doctor

questions to ask:
1. what kind of depression do I have?
2. should my depression be treated with medicines, psychotherapy or both?
3. how might my depression affect my appetite or weight?
4. How might my sleep be affected?
5. Could other health conditions be contributing to my depression?
6. Could my depression be causing me physical pain?
7. Do I need medicine for my depression?
8. What are the side effects of the medicine?
9.Do certain symptom of depression need extra treatment (sleep issues for example)?
10. What kind of life style changes would help with my symptoms of depression?
11. What about alternative treatments?
12. ***  What should I do in an emergency**?

I think that is a pretty great list to find info you need if you receive the depression diagnosis?  Any thoughts on this or think anything is missing?
2 Responses
Avatar universal
As usual, I'm going to give a caveat Mom and I have been differing on for a long time.  First of all, a general practitioner is not trained in diagnosing depression.  They do study mental illness a tiny bit, but depression is a major mental illness that can only be diagnosed by an expert.  General docs are not experts in much of anything, as they have to do so much in our system of medicine in so little time.  It takes a fair amount of time talking to diagnose a mental illness as opposed to feeling sad or feeling grief or having a bad spell.  A first appointment with a psychiatrist is generally 45 minutes.  All appointments with a psychologist are 50 minutes or more.   Appointments with a general doc are 15 minutes of actual treatment unless you're very wealthy and have a concierge physician who takes time or see 0ne who practices integrated medicine, neither of which take insurance.  Psychologists spend the most time of any other professional studying psychology.  Psychiatrists study a few months.  Regular docs a mention in a textbook.  Everyone gets to decide for themselves but before you get treated for depression you have to get a proper diagnosis.  What your regular doc can do better is test you for a host of physiological problems that can mimic depression but aren't depression -- a psychologist can't do this and most psychiatrists won't.  The other quibble is, "do I need medicine?"  Need is a very strong word.  Remember that when you mention medication to a doctor, you're very likely to get medication.  That's mostly what docs do -- they really mostly don't know how to do anything else.  They don't know how to do therapy -- psychiatrists know how to do it but usually don't, and even when they do, they give you less time and charge a lot more than a psychologist does with less training.  What the psychiatrist has more training in than other docs or psychologists is medication, so before you ask these things of a doctor, ask them of yourself and your friends and family.  How do you see you?  How do they see you?  How is your life going?  Are you functioning alright or not functioning at all?  In other words, do your homework before you see a psychiatrist, because medication is so overprescribed in the US it's become a national crisis.  When you truly need it you need it, but if you don't, you might still end up with it, so be wary out there.  
2 Comments
The intent of this was to help people get some ideas of good things to ask their doctors if in the situation of feeling like they are depressed. To that, I hope they can think of these questions when talking to their doctors.
And my intent was to reinforce your point but also protect people from doctors.  What you say to a doctor can make a big difference in how you are treated.  Your post was great help.  I hope I made it a little more protective of people.  Not detracting but adding, Mom.  Two heads better than one and all that.  Peace, Mom, have a good holiday.
1616953 tn?1443839111
I would only like to add that sometimes a GP can do a good diagnosis.  This requires a couple things that may not be very common but I wanted to put this out there.  If you have seen the doctor regularly for years and they actually know you is #1.  If they do doctors visits that are longer then 15 minutes.  I agree that these in and out doctors visits aren't good for a diagnosis of a complex issue like depression. I believe if you have a long association with your doctor its more likely you can get a longer visit.  

Ok, so assuming that happens and the doctor gives you a diagnosis of depression.  Are they giving you a referal to a PDoc or going into see a therapist?  If not I agree its less likely to be a good diagnosis.  Just remember these other two people you will probably be meeting for the first time and I sometimes wonder if they are like hammers that see everything as a nail?  Or in other words whatever symptoms you might have they try to fit it into some mental health diagnosis.

Its my experience that a GP that prescribes drug(s) for MI is going to be following up with you checking for side effects and if its effective or not.  And I think for getting dose and drug right a GP might be a better situation then a PDoc you see once a year.
Have an Answer?
Top Mood Disorders Answerers
Avatar universal
Arlington, VA
Learn About Top Answerers
Didn't find the answer you were looking for?
Ask a question
Popular Resources
15 signs that it’s more than just the blues
Discover the common symptoms of and treatment options for depression.
We've got five strategies to foster happiness in your everyday life.
Don’t let the winter chill send your smile into deep hibernation. Try these 10 mood-boosting tips to get your happy back
Smoking substitute may not provide such a healthy swap, after all.
How to lower your heart attack risk.