Avatar universal

Crystalens HD unpredictability or degradation

I posted a question under the same above title on August 12 and was kindly answered by Dr. Oyakawa. After gathering further information, I posted the following comment 11 hours ago seeking a reply from Dr. Oyakawa. As I wonder if Dr. Oyakawa is still monitoring a August 12 thread, I am now posting the following comment as a new question in the hope of catching Dr. Oyakawa's attention.

To: Dr. Ray T Oyakawa
Thank you very much for your comments.

Unfortunately, I have Grade 4 (out of a maximum of 5) dense cataract in my right eye and cannot wait.

Since your comment, another doctor in Singapore also told me Crystalens HD is unpredictable.

After carefully reading your comments, I have the following questions:

1) Are you saying Crystalens HD does not lose accomodation over time?

2) Its "unpredictability" mentioned by 2 doctors in Singapore can be managed if the surgeon concerned has ample experience in Crystalens HD and if proper post operative management such as the use of reading glasses for 2 weeks and yag are applied?

3) Should the use of reading glasses be applied to only the patients who need reading glasses before cataract or before operation OR to all patients? I am 57, have myopia and no or little hyperopia and have never used reading glasses. For the 2 weeks after Crytalens HD implantation, should I use or not use reading glasses or even wear myopia glasses for seeing long distance?

4} If yag of the anterior/posterior capsule can correct the corresponding hyperopia and myopia, I wonder why it has not been mentioned by the doctors in Singapore? To put it another way, if yag is a readily available remedy, then why "unpredictability" is such a big issue?

Your answers will be invaluable to me.
6 Responses
Sort by: Helpful Oldest Newest
711220 tn?1251891127
The HD is more sensitive to residual astigmatism and refractive error.  The AT50 is more forgiving and micromonovision works better.  You can target the non-dominant eye slightly myopic and improve near vision with a slight decrease in distance vision.  A patient using both eyes will see both distance and near well.  Micromonovison does not work with the HD and you have to target both eyes to plano (zero) or +.25.  The AT50 targets are  -0.25 for the dominant eye and -.50  to -.75 for the nondominant eye.

HD near vision improve with time and does not degrade.

You can see fairly well with upto 1.00 of residual astigmatism with the AT50, but with the HD astigmatism has to be .50 or less.

I use atropine for all my Crystalens patients and have them use readers for two weeks.  If the pupil reacts on day 5, I put in one more drop of atropine.  If you were a ble to read before cataract surgery without reader, you were nearsighted.  To see well at distance the Crystalens has to correct the near sightedness.  Therefore is you are to see well at distance without glasses, you will nead reader to see near.

The yagging of the anterior capsule for residual hyperopia is not well understood by most Crystalens surgeons.  Also, most surgeon do not know how to predicatably control astigmatism.  Most surgeons use a fixed depth LRI blade.  We learned from the RK days that you need to make a cut in the cornea to 90% depth to get a good effect.  Also, it is difficult to measure the thickness of the peripheral cornea with standard pachymeters and most surgeons do not have a micrometer adjusted LRI blade-very expensive to do depth adjusted LRI.  Google Nichamin  NAPA nomogram.

Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Thank you very much for your reply.

After carefully reading it, it appears that Crystalens HD's predictability and post operative remedy (if necessary) may be best managed by a surgeon who has ample experience in using Crystalens and who is well-versed in capsule yagging and variable-depth LRI. Careful and frequent follow-ups are also important.

As I live in Hong Kong where Crystalens is new, I have 2 options:
1) Go to Singapore where Crystalens experience is higher but can still be improved.
2) Go to the US where Crystalens Center of Excellence Award doctors can be found.

Still I cannot afford to stay long in either place for frequent follow-ups.

Is there anything that can be done to shorten my stay? To warrant good if not best results, what is the minimum time to stay?

Please advise.

Many Thanks in advance.

You mentioned "...you will need reader to see near." Do you mean just for the adjusting period of 2 weeks after surgery. My understanding is, over time, Crystalens HD normally achieves workable uncorrected near vision beyond 40 cm.  
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
I would say if you really want a Crystalens then a Crystalens Center of Excelence is a good start, However...This title is granted by the makers of the Crystalens and I don't know what their exact requirements are for granting this title.  I believe they need only to implant 100 Crystalens sucsessfully to obtain this title but I'm not 100% sure.  I don't know how they measure a sucessful implantation but I do know my doctor chalked mine up as a sucsess being 20/20 even though I cannot read a license plate at six feet. That with many side effects included at no additional charge.  Yes, he held the "Center of Exelence" title.   If you do decide to go through with the Crystalens, I would sugest that you go with an Opthamologist who takes his time with your pre op evaluation and measurements.  This is a very good indicator of how much time he/she will dedicate to you post op should a problem arise and may avoid a problem in the first place.  Good Luck!  
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Thank you for your comment and suggestion. I wonder what had happened to you and what has been done to correct or improve your situation.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
From Dr.O's initial response am I correct to assume that the Crystalens HD is not the best choice for one, such as myself, with a fair amount of astigmatism ?  Also, I should seek a surgeon skilled and with equipment to perform variable depth LRI?
Dr. Dell is in Austin, about 4 hours south of Dallas--how would I find a qualified surgeon with this micrometer adjustable blade locally?

Thank you once again for your skilled guidance; perhaps I should travel to Los Angeles!
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Probably not worth the trip to L.A.  I have been to many Ophthalmologists in the L.A. area and I wouldn't presume they are any better than those is Austin.  I find these "Beverly Hills" based practices don't spend the necessary amount of time on pre or post op with their patients.
Helpful - 0
Have an Answer?

You are reading content posted in the Eye Care Community

Top General Health Answerers
177275 tn?1511755244
Kansas City, MO
Avatar universal
Grand Prairie, TX
Avatar universal
San Diego, CA
Learn About Top Answerers
Didn't find the answer you were looking for?
Ask a question
Popular Resources
Discharge often isn't normal, and could mean an infection or an STD.
In this unique and fascinating report from Missouri Medicine, world-renowned expert Dr. Raymond Moody examines what really happens when we almost die.
Think a loved one may be experiencing hearing loss? Here are five warning signs to watch for.
When it comes to your health, timing is everything
We’ve got a crash course on metabolism basics.
Learn what you can do to avoid ski injury and other common winter sports injury.