Aa
Aa
A
A
A
Close
1253246 tn?1332073310

Milk Thistle???

Very Interesting I must say!!!


New evidence implies that milk thistle interrupts the Hepatitis C virus' reproduction and proliferation cycles.

by Nicole Cutler, L.Ac.

For centuries, the extract from the milk thistle plant has been used to improve liver function. This practice is widely recognized - especially by the millions of people living with chronic Hepatitis C - a viral infection that can cause progressive damage to the liver. Hundreds of studies have provided evidence that silymarin, milk thistle's extract, is a potent liver cell protector. However, there have also been an abundance of conflicting reports regarding milk thistle's ability to directly affect the Hepatitis C virus. Providing even more reason for those with Hepatitis C to take milk thistle, a new study tips the scales of doubt by showing that silymarin exerts multiple effects against the lifecycle of the Hepatitis C virus.

Two previous studies that have indicated silymarin's usefulness against Hepatitis C include:

· The February 2008 issue of Hepatology looked at milk thistle use among 1,145 participants in the HALT-C study, sponsored by the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Disease. Although milk thistle users in this study showed similar liver enzyme levels and Hepatitis C viral loads to non-users, those taking milk thistle showed fewer liver-related symptoms and an improved quality of life.

· The March 2010 issue of Gastroenterology published a French study where researchers evaluated a commercially available intravenous preparation of silibinin - the most active component of silymarin - in those with the Hepatitis C virus. The researchers agreed that silibinin inhibited Hepatitis C polymerase function - a result comparable to what the STAT-C (specifically targeted antiviral therapy for Hepatitis C) drugs can do - without their accompanying hazards.

The new study that further identifies milk thistle as an anti-Hepatitis C substance examined the antiviral properties and mechanisms of silymarin on cultured (grown in a lab) human liver cells infected with the virus. The study, funded in part by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), was published in the June 2010 edition of the journal, Hepatology.

After growing human liver cells and infecting them with the Hepatitis C virus, the cells were exposed to either standard Hepatitis C drug treatment or a diluted dose of silymarin. The researchers then found the following:

· Silymarin prevented the entry and fusion of the Hepatitis C virus into the target liver cells.

· Silymarin inhibited the ability of the virus to produce RNA, thus interfering with a portion of the virus' lifecycle.

· When measured against untreated cells, silymarin significantly decreased viral load (although to a lesser degree than treatment with interferon did).

· Silymarin prevented the cell-to-cell spread of the Hepatitis C virus.

Upon carefully taking all of the variables into account, the researchers concluded that silymarin's antiviral action appears to include blocking the entry and transmission of the Hepatitis C virus, possibly by targeting the host cell.

Experts agree that more well-structured trials are needed to understand, quantify and verify silymarin's effectiveness against the Hepatitis C virus. More ammunition is required to break down the wall of doubt surrounding this herb's contribution to the Hepatitis C community. In the meantime, there is sufficient evidence confirming silymarin's ability to protect liver cells and improve liver function - two properties that everyone with Hepatitis C could benefit from.
28 Responses
Sort by: Helpful Oldest Newest
1225178 tn?1318980604
" When measured against untreated cells, silymarin significantly decreased viral load (although to a lesser degree than treatment with interferon did)."

The article even says it doesn't work as well as tx... so why even mess with it? I guess I would try it if I couldn't take the meds for tx.

Diane
Helpful - 0
1454997 tn?1285868473
Thanks everyone.  I think I have an answer to my original question.

I read so much about it but my doctor kept telling me 'no'. I see now that it needs better testing for efficacy and drug interactions.  Bali05 made a good point that it might make the medicines that I'm on right now, less effective.  I think I'm best sticking with the medicine that I'm on.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
I have been calling clinical trials. One asked if I had had a flu shot (never) so I could be included. she asked about herbs or health product. I told her I take vit E. (just started) she was ok with that. I told her I wanted to start taking vit D. she was ok with that. I told her I just bought milk thistle but had not taken one yet. She said dont that would not be ok.   Today I went and screened @ another clinical trial. The doctor said dont take it it , you would be just be wasting your money... He seems like a knowlegable doctor. Im dying to pop a thistle pill. But not. Maybe I'll go trade them for D vitimin.
Helpful - 0
979080 tn?1323433639
you really should asked him that question directly and please we would like to hear the answer
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
I wonder why he would tell me that it was fine? I haven't taken any or even bought any for that matter.. I think I will take you guys advice. I wanna beat this crap.. Thanks!! :o)
Helpful - 0
179856 tn?1333547362
Missy I totally agree with Bali and we have discussed this many times over the years and whileI am no rocket scientist who can remember every detail I am relatively sure we are not supposed to take it exactly for that reason.

With any drug while ON treatment if you cannot 100% disprove that it will not cause any problem it's totally NOT worth taking it.

Treatment is hard enough to succeed with and beat this stupid disease but to give yourself less odds by accident?

I think if you put milk thistle in here in the search feature there will be 100s of doctors who have told thier patients fine but not on treatment.

Helpful - 0
979080 tn?1323433639
Guess your doctor knows something many others don`t.

i am usually all for protecting your liver , slowing and or reversing fibrosis ect.... but NOT
while on treatment.
How do you know that Milk Thistle for example does`nt clear out SOC meds out of liver
to quickly by trying to detoxify it ?
What can have a beneficial effect normally does not nessecarily mean it is good on tx.

Pre tx I took lots of quality pharmaceutical grade Milk Thistle from Germany so it was regulated with garanteed Silibin potencies It had zero effect on my viral load.
There are also absorption issues and there is a trial where Silibin is administered
intraveneously also in Germany that showed some response but it had to be done very often
meaning you end up with an IV-pole next to you most of the time. End result only showed
a marginal HCV decline but no SVR as far as I remember. I studied that almost a year ago.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Just talked to my doctor and he said it was fine to take the milk thistle while on treatment!!
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
I will check before I take it, I've got a call in to the doctors office now.. Thanks guys!!
Helpful - 0
179856 tn?1333547362
And again I do not believe we are supposed to take it while on treatment so be careful.  Whether it has merit or not I thought that was a foundational belief around here....

Acupunturists advising supplements well go figure!

Just dont put too much stock in anything really helping you that much except killing off the virus - at the end of the day all else is hopeful at best and that's about it.
Helpful - 0
87972 tn?1322661239
Cindy, the article quoted above is interesting, but the overview itself is written by Nicole Cutler, L.Ac. This is a degree for acupuncture, so I’m not sure she herself is qualified to provide advice. The references to published, peer reviewed journals of course might carry some weight. Her summary at the end sounds like sage counsel:

“Experts agree that more well-structured trials are needed to understand, quantify and verify silymarin's effectiveness against the Hepatitis C virus….”

Bill
Helpful - 0
315996 tn?1429054229
Maybe I will start taking Walmart or Puritan. Spending a furtune on Life Extension super whatever. Don't think I'm getting 1000mg a day however. god I spend so much money on these nutrients. But smarter to do that, follow suggestions here by HR et al, than not to. . . .
Helpful - 0
315996 tn?1429054229
I saw one study that said the Walmart brand, Spring Valley, had the most honest contents. This was for knee joing stuff, you know, those two items, can't remember the names.
Helpful - 0
179856 tn?1333547362
Doc told me NOT to take it ON treatment so check that out.

Helpful - 0
1253246 tn?1332073310
Puritans Pride is the maker .Google it and youll find they make every vitamin know to man!!!
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Yes I agree. I do buy the brads at wal-mart but they contain little of silymarin.I take 4000-6000 mg a day just to get the desired dose of silymarin…
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Thanks. I just bought some over the internet. Was buying a more expensive brand and taking 3 times a day . It was doing anything for me, maybe the brand or not enough dosing. I'll try the one from Walmart. Can't beat that pricing.
Helpful - 0
789911 tn?1368636783
Does it matter what brand you take? I have heard people say that some brands like the stuff you can get at walmart or CVS....   is not very goodl    can you just take  silymarin supplement since that is the active ingredient in milk thistle?  I think I have seen both in the health food store.
Helpful - 0
901131 tn?1293744553
puritans.com
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Thanks Magnum!! Thanks to you to Boo, but I have no idea what a Puritans Pride is!! Lol
Helpful - 0
29837 tn?1414534648
You can buy it at Wal-Mart. It's the Spring Valley brand at 90 softgels @ 1000mg. each.
About $6.50. That will last you about 3 months @ 1 softgel per day.

Magnum
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
OK, the pills I have state that they are 325mg of Milk Thistle Seed and 75mg of Milk Thistle Seed Powder Extract Standardized to 80% Silymarin. So is this a 325mg pill, a 400mg pill or something else based on the 80% Silymarin statement? The label's "Suggested Use" statement indicates to take "1 capsule 3 times daily". Would that be a 1200mg regimen per day?? What is the difference between the seed and "seed powder extract"?

I've been taking 1 daily, but the prior posts make me wonder if I'm just wasting my money by taking too little for it to have any effect.

For those concerned about taking too much, here's this passage from the wikipedia silymarin page at:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silibinin

"The acute toxicity of silymarin and silybin were investigated by oral and intravenous route in various animal species. No mortality or any signs of adverse effects were observed after silymarin at oral doses of 20 g/kg in mice and 1 g/kg in dogs. The 50% lethal dose (LD50) after intravenous infusion values are 400 mg/kg in mice, 385 mg/kg in rats and 140 mg/kg in rabbits and dogs. These data demonstrate that the acute toxicity of silymarin is very low.[citation needed]

Similarly, its subacute and chronic toxicity are very low; the compound is also devoid of embryotoxic potential."
Helpful - 0
901131 tn?1293744553
Puritan's pride has Milk Thistle in a 1000mg pill, I use them because consumler Labs testing them to be accurate. Nazzareno I read how most of the supplement is not absorbed and talking with my GI decided to increase my dosage. I did it gradually over a few years. Stick with a 1000mg for awile. I get blood test done every 4 months.Selenium is also a good supplement at 200mcg a day and R Alpha Lipoic Acid, I take 300mg a day.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Where can I find milk thistle?? And can I add that while taken pegasys and ribavirin?? Thanks in advance!!
Helpful - 0
2
Have an Answer?

You are reading content posted in the Hepatitis C Community

Top Hepatitis Answerers
317787 tn?1473358451
DC
683231 tn?1467323017
Auburn, WA
Learn About Top Answerers
Didn't find the answer you were looking for?
Ask a question
Answer a few simple questions about your Hep C treatment journey.

Those who qualify may receive up to $100 for their time.
Explore More In Our Hep C Learning Center
image description
Learn about this treatable virus.
image description
Getting tested for this viral infection.
image description
3 key steps to getting on treatment.
image description
4 steps to getting on therapy.
image description
What you need to know about Hep C drugs.
image description
How the drugs might affect you.
image description
These tips may up your chances of a cure.
Popular Resources
A list of national and international resources and hotlines to help connect you to needed health and medical services.
Herpes sores blister, then burst, scab and heal.
Herpes spreads by oral, vaginal and anal sex.
STIs are the most common cause of genital sores.
Condoms are the most effective way to prevent HIV and STDs.
PrEP is used by people with high risk to prevent HIV infection.