Avatar universal

Broken locked thumb and differing doctor opinions

Hello everyone,

Ok the story goes like this: About a month ago (October 18, 2011) I had a motorbike accident. I was OK but after I took off my gloves I noticed my left thumb looked a bit weird. I went to A&E where I had x-rays and was told I had an avulsion fracture at the base of the thumb and a break at the top of the thumb (on the distal phalange) and they put an Elastoplast splinter.

1 week later I had to visit the UCLH fracture clinic where an orthopaedic told me it should heal with conservative treatment and they changed the Elastoplast splinter with a plastic one.

3 weeks later (total 4wks) I went back and had a new set of x-rays. This time a different orthopaedic came over, he took the splinter off, and very simply told me that because the bone has gone in the joint I will not be able to move the tip of my thumb anymore but a few degrees..

This obviously shocked me, especially after all the reassurance I was given before, and since I am in general quite active (do drums, boxing). So, I immediately visited a private orthopaedic for a second opinion who had another set of x-rays done:

Left thumb bottom aspect

Left thumb side aspect (as you look the hand from the top)

He had a different opinion. He thinks that there is enough room in the joint for movement and that I will probably be able to bend it again but sent me for an MRI scan as well, which I am having next week.

My thumb at the moment feels locked on that position and is still bruised at the joint but with a bit of slow repetitive movement exercise I managed to get a few extra degrees of movement than when I got the splinter off (tendons seem to be OK). So, my questions are:

1) Do you think that I will be able to bend my thumb anymore?
2) Is there any exercise I should be doing?
3) Should there have been a different course of treatment in the initial weeks?

Any information will be highly appreciated.

Thank you
3 Responses
Sort by: Helpful Oldest Newest
700223 tn?1318165694
This is a fracture of the articular surface of the DIP joint of the thumb. On the images you provided, the fracture appears to involve about 40% of the articular surface with a reasonable amount of displacement. Although the bone will certainly heal, you may lose some motion and may be subject to post-traumatic arthritis in the future.  At this point, the fracture should be fairly well healed; I would likely institute a range of motion program and observe your progress.
Helpful - 1
Avatar universal
Thank you.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
To see the links of the x-rays I've posted above, you just need to copy/paste the URL to the address bar of your browser but I will try to repost the pictures here under a different format:

Left thumb bottom aspect

Left thumb side aspect (as you look the hand from the top)
Helpful - 0

You are reading content posted in the Orthopedics & Sports Medicine Forum

Popular Resources
Find out if PRP therapy right for you.
Tips for preventing one of the most common types of knee injury.
Tips and moves to ease backaches
How to bounce back fast from an ankle sprain - and stay pain free.
Patellofemoral pain and what to do about it.
Herpes sores blister, then burst, scab and heal.