Definitely conisistant with plantar strain, but if the pain persists, see your foot specialist,
I have been icing and stretching. I tried every shoe in my closet with and without orthotics. Nothing is helping and now the ball of my foot and heel hurt too. The pain has almost formed a line from the ball to my heel. Is this normal for a strained plantar fascia?
Sounds like you may have strained the planter fascia. Icing and stretching should give you some relief. In addition, any shoes with a good arch may be able to take the place of your orthotics for the time being. In the meantime, you could try over the counter inserts for temporary relief.