I had three prizes for mine, a bottle of wine, a $10 gas card and a make up bag with brushes,eye shadows and lip gloss.
I did $5 candles from dolor store each one had different designs, scents, and containers. It's cheap easy and who doesn't like candles.
I went to a baby shower once where they gave out gift cards for different places, which I thought was really cool. Like $5 Starbucks, $10 Target, $10 gas card, & $5 Subway. There were many different places. But I thought that was a great idea because it's definitely something that people can utilize & the prizes can go to male or female if your having a co-ed shower. Gift cards are also relatively cheap & you don't have to wrap them. I'll be doing this at my shower. Hope this helps :-)
Dollar store little care baskets?
I'm going to have a coach purse and some nice candles as bigger prizes, then dollar store gift bags for other ones, they will all be wrapped so ppl can't pick the good ones hehe
I went with two big prizes and the rest small like pretty purfume lotions or candles and the big ones were liquor bottles and a wonderful set of glasses :p
Check Michaels. They have a great dollar section and you can easily make a nice gift bag for 5 dollars. They usually have stationary items, bags, small frames, lots of randomness but easy and inexpensive.
At mine they did germ x for prizes the little bottles and for another prize they did a candle warmer.