Abigail Rose
Abigail Marie
Abigail Taylor
Abigail Breann
Abigail Reese
I think both middle names sound masculine and I've know an Abigail who says she was made fun of as a child, and had the nickname "flabby abby".
I absolutely love Abigail Blake! Beautiful name
What about Abigail Nicole or Abigail Renee