No, that's not true... we have a member of the forum, whose TSH always stays at about 18-23 and she's not the least hypo. On the flip side of that, my TSH has been at < 0.01 for the past 8 yrs and I've never been hyper...
Once the thyroid has been removed, as yours has or it's died out from Hashimoto's, as many of ours have, TSH is totally irrelevant. As I said before, it neither causes nor alleviates symptoms.
The only things that matter are Free T4, Free T3 levels and symptoms. It's important to note that some symptoms can "cross over" and apply to both hyper and hypo... those include, but aren't limited to rapid heart rate, pounding heart, anxiety, depression, fatigue, lethargy, etc.
There are some vitamin/minerals that we look at if Free T4/Free T3 are at recommended levels and symptoms have not been alleviated.
They didn't check your TSH when you left the hospital because it wasn't relevant then. TSH is a pituitary hormone that stimulates the thyroid to produce more thyroid hormones; TSH neither causes nor alleviates symptoms. You don't have a thyroid so most of the time TSH is not irrelevant. They took you off your levo in order to raise your TSH to do the RAI, but what they were really doing was lowering your thyroid hormone levels, as evidenced by TSH levels. They should not have waited as long as they did. It wasn't really the high TSH that made you sick - it was the low/lack of thyroid hormones that made your body start to shut down, since thyroid hormones control several body processes, such as heart rate, metabolism, body temperature, etc.
You need to make sure you're being tested for Free T4, not just T4, as that indicates Total T4, which is obsolete. Your result and its reference range do look like what we, typically, see for Free T4; it should be specified on the report.
You should also make sure your doctor begins testing for Free T3, which again, should not be mistaken for Total T3 as they are not the same tests and don't give the same information. Free T3 is the hormone used by individual cells in your body... It must be converted "from" Free T4, which is more or less a storage form of hormone and is not used directly by the cells.
Even though you have high levels of Free T4, you can still be hypo, if your body isn't adequately converting that Free T4 to the usable Free T3.
Always be sure to specify Free T4 and Free T3... that's very important.
I'm sure you'll have to go off the levothyroxine again in order to take the RAI, and they will want your TSH higher, but it doesn't have to be 208 and your FT4 doesn't have to be 0.2. They should never have let you go as long as they did. There's also a low iodine diet you're supposed to go on, prior to RAI... I'm not real familiar with it, but I don't think it's so strict that you end up losing all your nutrients... You might want to ask for a dietician, experienced with the Low Iodine Diet before you do it again.
Just to supplement the good info from Barb, have a look at the following link. From that info It seems that your doctor may have overlooked several alternatives that could have mitigated the extreme condition you encountered after being placed on a low replacement dose of T4 post- thyroidectomy, and then stopping it for 6 weeks before re-testing, in preparation for RAI.
http://www.endocrineweb.com/conditions/thyroid-cancer/radioactive-iodine-papillary-thyroid-cancer
I'm sorry to hear you went through such a hard time. I'm a little confused about a couple of things, so it would be good if you could clear those up...
I'm not sure what you're referring to as "toxic dose" of Synthroid...it's true that Synthroid is the same thing as Levothyroxine - Synthroid is the brand name; levothyroxine is the generic. What dosage was given to you?
It takes 4-6 weeks for a dosage of T4 medication, such as Synthroid or Levothryoxine to reach full potential in your blood. Did you ever have a Free T4 test done? Free T3 is the active thyroid hormone that's actually used by the individual cells in your body.
It's customary to be off thyroid hormones prior to RAI, however, I'm not sure why your body was so depleted of other nutrients.
To my knowledge, myxedema is not a lifelong crisis. You don't say how long ago this took place, so even though you may be back on thyroid hormones, you were very hypo and it will take a while for your body to recover. Nothing with hypothyroidism works quickly, because of the time it takes T4 meds to reach potential in your system.
What daily dosage are you currently taking of Synthroid/Levothyroxine? Do you know what your actual thyroid hormone levels are? You should be getting tested for Free T4, Free T3 and TSH. If you have the most current test results, it would good if you could post them here for us. Also, please include reference ranges, since those vary lab to lab and have to come from your own report.