It is my opinion, yes. I won't say it never happens, but I would say, based on 32 years of experience and seeing this once (and I'm not so sure even about that time) that this is an uncommon, rare event. However, some people get them in both places at the same sexual encounter, giving oral sex to and kissing the same person.
Terri
Terri, would like to clarify something...
"...they are less contagious to others and not contagious to other people who already have HSV 1 infection. "
Is it your opinion that someone who is in the 60 - 90% of the population that has HSV-1 antibodies cannot contract a genital HSV-1 infection?
1) Do HSV-1 infections, genitally, recur less often than HSV-2? Are they equally contagious?
They recur less and because they recur and shed less, they are less contagious to others and not contagious to other people who already have HSV 1 infection.
2) Would having HSV-1 make me more susceptible to HSV-2? Could these boils be HSV-2?
No, if anything, they might make you less susceptible to HSV 2.
3) Are my odds of transmission of genital HSV-1 to a partner lower or equal to HSV-2? Lower.
4) I thought HSV-1 only occurred in the oral region. I know I had canker sores as a kid; why would the initial outbreak appear on my genitalia? Wouldn't I have had the antibodies to prevent that? If you had had oral herpes as a kid (canker sores are not caused by herpes), they would you likely not have gotten it genitally. You likely got it genitally from someone giving you oral sex or from having intercourse with someone who had genital HSV 1.
5) Would herpes look like whiteheads? Would they go away as quickly as they have been (under a week)?
Most people would not describe herpes as looking like a whitehead, but its possible.
6) I've dealt with cyst-type things on my face twice in the past year that required antibiotics. Could these boil-like bumps be related to that?
Probably not no.
7) My STD clinic no longer does HSV tests (SO RIDICULOUS); how should I proceed from here? Dermatologist? OB/GYN? Regular doctor? If this is NOT a recurrence, I would like to know what it is.
A dermatologist would be a good idea or ob. You need a swab test taken of the lesions, most certainly
Terri