What about a cheap tumbler cup filled with candy? Or filled with cheap nail polish, toe nail clipper , travel size bath stuff?
Or some jewelery on sale. Cato and Bealls always have necklaces on sale for under $3.
Gift card for a movie theater ($5-$10 would be good), bath soaps, kid toys if a kid wins (if kids are going of course), you could also do some disney things for prizes like the coffee cups and stuff. My shower theme is polka dots/minnie mouse because I'm having a girl too. :)
@Avasmommy19 I was going to do that but I should have stated I'm trying to have the gifts unisex. I have men coming too and they said they will be playing games too.
@watermelon15 I like the cup filled with candy idea!
@ajsbaby and @danielleberger1 forgot all about gift certificates and gift cards great idea!
@danielleberger1 omg love the Disney cup idea too!!! I wanted to Minnie mouse too bit I got ahead of myself and had started with the decorations for the lion king lol