Aa
Aa
A
A
A
Close
Avatar universal

N-acetylcarnosine eye drops for cataract regression

Has anyone really tried N-acetylcarnosine (NAC) eye drops for seveal months?  What is your result?  I have beginning cataracts at 66 years of age, and heard about NAC eye drops from Nu-Eyes and Can-C.  I have used 4 or more drops of Nu-Eyes per day in each eye for nearly 8 months and have seen no improvement.  I don't think the cataract progression has even halted.  I don't know if this is a scam or ripoff, or just bad research and agressive marketing.  Maybe the manufacturers are not really making what was used in the clinical trials (all in Russia, not the U.S.).  Those who tried, get your experience noted.  The distributers have all the press now.  
12 Responses
Sort by: Helpful Oldest Newest
Avatar universal
I have used Nu-eyes ( that my eye doctor told me about) for over 10 years and they have slowed my cataracts.  When I first went to  eye doctors back then they all wanted to remove the cataracts but I kept looking until I found a Dr. that said it was way too soon for that and recommended Nu-eyes to me.  They have kept the cataracts at bay for over 10 years now. After using them for about a year he said the yellowing of the lens had lighten and I would probably not need surgery for a few years.  Well it has been 10 years  and I think in another 2 or 3 years I will consider their removal.  When I started using Nu-eyes it was only available by ordering it from England. I would recommend trying it to anyone, you have nothing to lose.  If it works for you like it did for me great and if it doesn't you are no worse off than you were to begin with.
Helpful - 0
1 Comments
334194 tn?1288289595

If it isnt labeled Rx, sold at a silly price at a controlled pharmacy, it doesn't work.   If its sold in a health store, is safe, and works..it's placebo.  Welcome to orthodox mecidine.




Helpful - 0
1332925 tn?1275426087
My attitude towards physicians is that they are well trained primates who may have some competency in their area of specialty, but should not be trusted in any other areas, and maybe not even in their areas of practice. I speak from much experience here.

With regard to DMSO.  If you google it you will see numerous, make that countless, people using it, especially coaches and veterinarians.  I have used it for various minor ailments for 40 years, always with success.  No doubt the good Dr Hagan will tell you that the animals were just benefiting from a placebo affect.  Yes, it can be harmful.  Do not, under any circumstances go swimming in it.  Also, it is not a good idea to put harmful chemicals like turpentine on the same area as DMSO as it will end up in your blood stream.  Not a good thing.

If you want to see how physicians deal with non traditional cures, just look up the history of ulcer treatment and how long it took for physicians to accept the idea that such were caused by a bacteria.  Dr. Hagan probably still does not accept that idea. :-)
Helpful - 0
1332925 tn?1275426087
My attitude towards physicians is that they are well trained primates who may have some competency in their area of specialty, but should not be trusted in any other areas, and maybe not even in their areas of practice. I speak from much experience here.

With regard to DMSO.  If you google it you will see numerous, make that countless, people using it, especially coaches and veterinarians.  I have used it for various minor ailments for 40 years, always with success.  No doubt the good Dr Hagan will tell you that the animals were just benefiting from a placebo affect.  Yes, it can be harmful.  Do not, under any circumstances go swimming in it.  Also, it is not a good idea to put harmful chemicals like turpentine on the same area as DMSO as it will end up in your blood stream.  Not a good thing.

If you want to see how physicians deal with non traditional cures, just look up the history of ulcer treatment and how long it took for physicians to accept the idea that such were caused by a bacteria.  Dr. Hagan probably still does not accept that idea. :-)
Helpful - 0
757137 tn?1347196453
I have just had a breakthrough development with NAC and MSM eye drops. See my post under "eye care" in the non-medical section listed today. Very, very exciting.
Helpful - 0
7 Comments
How do I find the post you are referring to?  I am not able to find a "non-medical section" on this website.
=
Dr. Hagan, can you please help me find the "non-medical section" allmymarbles is referring to?
Snake Oil...
All of the material posted by allmymarbles is false and specious. Probably he/she sells the study. THAT POSTING WAS EIGHT YEARS AGO. IF IT WAS A BREAKTHROUGH THEN DOCTORS ALL OVER THE WORLD WOULD BE USING IT AND THERE WOULD BE NO WORLD PROBLEM WITH CATARACTS.  THERE IS ALWAYS SOME 'CURE' ON THE INTERNET THAT THE UNSCRUPULOUS OR DISHONEST ARE WILLING TO SELL YOU.  
While I believe that “THERE IS ALWAYS SOME 'CURE' ON THE INTERNET THAT THE UNSCRUPULOUS OR DISHONEST ARE WILLING TO SELL YOU” is true, I also believe that those who live in glass houses, i.e., those who practice conventional medicine, shouldn’t throw stones:

http://www.qcc.cuny.edu/socialsciences/ppecorino/MEDICAL_ETHICS_TEXT/Chapter_3_Moral_Climate_of_Health_Care/Reading-Death-Rate-Doctor-Strike.htm

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/02/22/medical-errors-third-leading-cause-of-death-in-america.html

https://www.chrisbeatcancer.com/chemo-kills-up-to-50-percent-of-patients-in-some-hospitals/

https://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2011/10/26/prescription-drugs-number-one-cause-preventable-death-in-us.aspx

It is because of the statistics in these articles that people like me (and allmymarbles, I suspect) look for treatments that are not only safe and affordable, but that actually work.  Some go to integrative medicine doctors who use supplements and “alternative” modalities, but some are fortunate to live in an area served by one or more functional medicine doctors.  FMDs are conventional medicine doctors who have finally realized that what they learned in medical school has done nothing to help their patients get well, so they spend even more time and money going to conferences to get a REAL medical education, one that teaches them how to help their patients actually obtain real health, without the use of deadly pharmaceuticals.  

Generally, these FMDs teach their patients how to improve their health through diet, lifestyle, exercise, sunshine, and finding peace (managing stress).  Because it is impossible to get to the root cause of a person’s illness in a 10-15 minute office visit, they spend 2-3 hours with the patient on the initial visit and another hour or more on the first follow-up visit.  They go home at night feeling good about their work and sleep soundly because they see their patients getting well and staying well.  And even though they do not accept insurance (meaning their patients must pay all costs, including labs, out of pocket), their waiting rooms are overflowing from word-of-mouth referrals by satisfied “customers” whose lives have been turned around by what they have been taught by the FMD.  

After searching for almost a year, I recently discovered an FMD who practices 170 miles from my home, and he spent close to 3 hours with me, digging deeply into my symptoms, habits and medical history.  After only 90 days of changes in my diet and supplements, my worst symptoms are gone.  He has me on high doses of ionic minerals and says it will be 18-24 months before my body will be fully remineralized, after which he expects I will need only one yearly office visit to recheck a few labs to be sure I am still on course.  Because he advocates that his patients get the majority of their nutrients from clean, organic, pasture-raised food, my monthly supplement bill decreases as my health increases.  He and all his staff are readily available via email to answer any questions I have.

If this sounds like the type of practice you or someone you know would like to have, or if you yourself have health challenges that conventional medicine has failed to meet, check out https://www.ifm.org/certification-membership/.  The great majority of FMDs left conventional medicine after they or someone close to them developed a serious illness that multiple medical specialists failed to cure and in fact often made worse.  

God bless,
OmaLou
=
757137 tn?1347196453
I was referring to N- acetyl-carnosine, by the way.
Helpful - 0
757137 tn?1347196453
I spoke to my doctor about this preparation. Although not familiar with this particular product, he said it might possibly be good for clearing the cornea and the area outside the lens, but not the lens itself because of its lack of permeability. I had been trying it for four months and noticed an improvement for about two months, and then, nothing more. So maybe it merely had an effect on my cornea. I am pretty sure of the last because I had been having trouble with my contact lenses (they began to feel as if I hadn't cleaned them and were uncomfortable) and had to stop using them. After using the drops for a few weeks I was able to wear them comfortably again.

It is time for me to see my eye doctor again. He will be able to tell me if I have realized any improvement.
Helpful - 0
233488 tn?1310693103
MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL
I am familiar with DMSO research, what true science there is shows it is not effective for cataracts and most of the other claims made for it. It falls into the same claims made that leatril cures all cancers. Turpentine is an effective solvent also. That doesn't make it good for humans.

JCH MD
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
It sure sounds like the DMSO solution was very effective for me901.  Did you read his email?  He didn't say that he read about it somewhere.  He clearly states that he had a personal experience.  

The fact is that DMSO is one of the most effective solvents.  Shouldn't you be looking into what made this particular DMSO solution effective rather that assume that me901 doesn't know what happened to him or her?
Helpful - 0
233488 tn?1310693103
MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL
There are thousands of worthless, often expensive, sometimes dangerous drops, ointments, pills, salves for stopping or disolving cataracts.

DMSO is NOT EFFECTIVE.  

DISREGARD THE RECOMMENDATION FROM ME 901  MANY OF THESE ARE POSTED BY THE PEOPLE THAT SEE THEM.

JCH III MD
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
I have just started using eye drops to dissolve my cataracts. I have an excellent doctor . He had these drops custom mixed for me. They are not the usual drops like canc or nu eyes. They are made from DMSO and some other stuff that I do not know. Formula- DMSO/VIT C/GLU .
He says they will work.
I started last night. 1 drop in my right eye.
I have 20/70 vision in that eye. It is getting worse quickly. A few months ago I had 20/50.
I got up this morning and could actually read my alarm clock. This is not due however to the cataract being dissolved but I think to moisture soaking into the lens. I have heard that this happens with the other type drops also.
I will post updates if I can to let you know if my vision gets better.

Just in case you do not know about DMSO. It is a solvent that is good for lots of stuff. It soaks into your skin and takes medication in with it.  So I suppose it is used in the eye drops to carry the other ingredients into the lens.
It is good for arthritis also.
Helpful - 0
177275 tn?1511755244
Hello userj   There is no scientific evidence that NAC, Similason or homeopathic medications or eye drops prevent cataracts from developing, slow their growth or make them go away. Contentions that they do would be somewhere between scam/ripoff and bad research.

JCH MD Board Certified Ophthalmologist
Helpful - 0
Have an Answer?

You are reading content posted in the Eye Care Community

Top General Health Answerers
177275 tn?1511755244
Kansas City, MO
Avatar universal
Grand Prairie, TX
Avatar universal
San Diego, CA
Learn About Top Answerers
Didn't find the answer you were looking for?
Ask a question
Popular Resources
Discharge often isn't normal, and could mean an infection or an STD.
In this unique and fascinating report from Missouri Medicine, world-renowned expert Dr. Raymond Moody examines what really happens when we almost die.
Think a loved one may be experiencing hearing loss? Here are five warning signs to watch for.
When it comes to your health, timing is everything
We’ve got a crash course on metabolism basics.
Learn what you can do to avoid ski injury and other common winter sports injury.