goolarra, thank you so much for your response, really, really appreciate it. I had bad news at work yesterday so have to take care of issues but will be back to comment later.
1) This is just my opinion as a fellow patient, you understand. Prescribing meds without labs is questionable to me. Yes, this should be symptom-driven treatment, but there's no point in burying your head in the sand, either. Did you bring him labs that he went on? The problem, to me, with the "shotgun approach" is twofold: a) many of us had symptoms we thought were not related to thyroid that resolved on thyroid meds, so yours might resolve when levels are corrected, and b) it's going to be impossible, starting that many meds at the same time, to isolate effects of each.
2) There are 19 mcg T4 and 4.5 mcg T3 in 30 mg Armour. Dose often (almost always) has to be adjusted, but it's better to start out low and increase slowly to avoid swinging hyper. If you take your second dose too late in the day, the T3 in the Armour can impact sleep. You can experiment with the time that works best for you, but most people avoid taking it much after 3 pm (on a "normal" sleep schedule). Some do late morning, some early afternoon.
3) The "related things" may resolve without separate treatment once thyroid hormone levels are right. Yes, they most likely are all connected. Just starting out as you are, thyroid meds alone might solve all your problems. If not, any lingering symptoms can be addressed separately once thyroid levels are right if that doesn't resolve them.
4) Classical answer: we're all different. Part of that depends on how long you've been hypo, how close your doctor gets to your optimal dose on your initial dose, general health, etc, etc.
p.s. It's not that Armour doesn't work. Many people who'd been on the old Armour with great success for years didn't react well at all to the reformulation. People on the new formula, who never took the old, are still having success with it.
p.s. do people still think the new Armour formula from 2009 doesn't work? or are people mostly still taking it and are well on it?