We've been having the same issues with our 4 year old for about 6 weeks. Your advice is spot-on and I appreciate it. We've been trying the same thing (door closing), but not right at bedtime....only when she comes out of her bedroom, which is sometimes several times a night. And we'd only close it for a bit.
I'm going to attempt the door closing right at bedtime and hope that it works succcesfully for us too.
So understand how hard it is to do that, but I guess we're teaching them to soothe themselves, and stop manipulating.
Thanks for your post...it's given me the courage to do the same!
Our son is 3.5 years old and was doing this too. He'd wake up 5-6 times a night crying and screaming and coming into our room each time if we didn't go to him. He was extremely overtired it was a vicious cycle. We finally had to make some major changes. We moved his bedtime an hour and a half earlier, put him down for naps earlier and then we did something that most parents shudder to hear. We turned his doorknob around and locked his bedroom door at nap and bedtime. After he fell asleep we'd unlock it for safety reasons, but he wouldn't know that.
Before we actually went that route we talked to our pediatrician. He also said it was a behavioral thing. He said that he'd had to do the same thing with one of his own kids. He told us to make sure the room was totally child proofed and he suggested using a babygate instead of locking the door. But since our son can open all those, it wasn't an option.
After the first two nights, he was sleeping straight through the night again and taking naps. After the first couple of nights, we didn't need to lock the door anymore. Just the idea it could be locked was enough to keep him in bed. I'm not sure why that made him sleep the whole night, I think maybe he knew he wasn't going to get any attention during the night and it made him stop waking himself up completely.
Over a month we were able to move his bedtime later by 45 minutes so he doesn't wake up super early in the morning. I'm sure I'll hear a lot of criticism for the choice we made, but it worked and he sleeps and acts so much better now, he's like a different child.
I will warn you, we've heard a lot of people, including my mother say that maybe we should have done something more first. But trust me, we tried everything--blackout shades, white noise, night lights, reward charts, incentives, all sorts of bedtime routines, long and short, everything people suggested we tried. It came down to this...Our son just needed to be left alone at night, as hard as that was for everyone at first. It was tough, I won't lie about that. Hearing him ask us to unlock the door was heartbreaking, it made me and my husband cry. But he's learned to go to sleep on his own again, and sleep through the night again. He's taking his naps and not fighting us about going to sleep.
I kept thinking it was a phase at first and he'd outgrow it. But after 6 months of the "phase", we were desperate for sleep. I think he'd still be doing it if we hadn't intervened.
I hope that helps you a little, whatever you decide to do.
I'm so frustrated. My 4 yr old 'wakes up' screaming and yelling several times a night. This has been going on for about 2 months. The dr thinks its behavioral and she'll grow out of it. We have done naps, early bedtimes, etc, but nothing seems to help. Does anybody have any suggestions or been thru this? If she will grow out of it, I hope it happens soon.
My son done the same thing. It was his Singular. He was having night terrors because of the medication. It took him around 2 months to work it out of his system once we took him off of the medicne.
My 4 year old daughter has been doing this also, she wakes up crying , but she wont talk to me or tell me what is wrong, or if she is in pain, nothing. And it takes me almost an hour it seems to calm her down and get back to sleep myself. It is stressful on me, cause I can't help her if she can't tell me. She speaks her mind any other time, but during these episodes she can not talk. Please help me.
My first guess would be night terrors. My doctor told us that it is very common for 3-5 year olds to go through a period of time of these.
Another possiblity is the growing pains. We only grow while we sleep so that is why the pains happen during the night. Our two year old is going through that. She will have a couple bad nights then be okay for a few.
Good luck and hang in there!