Basal temperature is not necessarily a good indication of thyroid status. One must go by Free T3 and Free T4... When I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism in 2008, my basal temperature was running at normal levels, if not high, all the time, but my TSH at diagnosis was 55.5 and my Free T4 was 0.6 (0.8-1.8). My doctor refused to test Free T3... He didn't remain my doctor for very long, especially, after my TSH plummeted to < 0.01 when I started on Synthroid, but my Free T4 was still at 0.6 and he started backing off on my med, in spite of all the symptoms...
You should also have your daughter tested for insulin resistance, which often goes hand in hand with hypothyroidism. I found that changing my diet to low carb, higher fat, made it much easier to lose weight, because fat doesn't spike the blood sugar like simple carbs do. I stick with veggies and healthful fats, like olive oil, avocado, coconut oil, butter, nuts, seeds, lean meats, etc.
Exercise is also key...
As far as medical thyroid testing goes, the most indicative & accurate for cellular thyroid function are: Free T3 (fT3), Free T4 (fT4) AND Reverse T3 (rT3).
All 3 are needed!
FT3/RT3 ratio is probably the most reliable marker for low cellular thyroid function. Ideally It should be higher than 20.
To my opinion though, we cannot find a better method to test than Dr. Barnes Basal Temperature Test. (there are several versions now)
I have devoted countless of hours, scanning through the studies and groundbreaking work of Dr. Barnes, The Father of Hypothyroidism, lol!
Simply brilliant and way ahead of his time!
Instructions For Taking Basal Body Temperature:
Use an ordinary oral or rectal glass (not digital) thermometer.
Shake down the thermometer the night before, and place it on your nightstand.
The first thing in the morning BEFORE you get out of bed, place the thermometer under your arm for ten(10) minutes.
Record the temperature reading and date right away!
Repeat for 10 days.
Normal Range: 97.6 to 98.2
Averages below this range indicate hypothyroidism.
In your daughter's case, Levothyroxine, which is T4, instead of converting
under ideal circumstances into T3, could be converting into Reverse T3, thus lowering further Free T3 (bioavailable T3)
So, should this be the case, she will likely benefit from Cytomel -which is only T3- and Natural Desiccated Thyroid - contains mainly T4 & T3 but also includes T1 & T2 , which are balancing thyroid hormones.
The minimum starting doses for both should be tried at first and her thyroid function monitored frequently, so periodic adjustments and tweaking can be made, until a good thyroid balance is achieved.
If you have any questions, please let me know.
Best wishes,
Niko