Thank you so much for your response!!
Hi and welcome to the Chiari forum.
First, let me say I really hate when a Dr gives Chiari a term like mild, and do not look further as to how it is affecting u, I am sure the pain u feel is not mild....so pet peeve of mine.
Next, u r right u can not compare, even with those that do have shoulder pain and had surgery , of those some have had relief of pain and others had an increase....as u r right many with Chiari do have other conditions related to Chiari and we do encourage u to have those ruled out b4 u consider surgery as they can affect how u feel and heal post op.
Syringomyelia, tethered cord, ICP.,POTS, sleep apnea, disk issues, scoliosis, ehlers-danlos....are a few.
Having the right Dr is also key, they will look to these related conditions and know how to approach surgery to help get u the best results....but we r all different and may respond to the drugs and meds used differently so that can affect how u heal too,.
Since u have a syrinx, surgery is the best option if it is growing....u have to keep a close eye on it.
Many members that have had surgery have a journal in their profile page....feel free to read those to get more info.