102999 tn?1326855784

Doc said 5000 iu of Vit D3 is WAY too much (and more)

Nothing frustrates me more than conflicting info. This is the amount a highly respected local nutritionist told me to take (she said she takes 6000). On this amount, my last level was a 73 (which seemed to be middle road). Now I am doubting everything I take (except Magnesium because that has changed my life).

Curious what others think...

Just for the heck of it, I will add others I take...

1000mg Vit C (ascorbate - buffered)

100mg CoQ10

1000mg Fish Oil (EPA 180/DHA 120)

B-100 Complex

Krebs Cycle Chelates:
     Calcium 600mg
     Iron 5mg
     iodine 100 mcg
     Magnesium 400mg
     Zinc 15mg
     Selenium 75 mcg
     Copper 1mg
     Maganese 2mg
     Chromium 100 mcg
     Molybdenum 25 mcg
     Sodium 10mg
     Potassium 100mg
     Boron 4mg
     Vanadium 50 mcg

Krebs Potassium/Magnesium Chelate:
     Magnesium 250mg
     Potassium 100mg

1000 mcg Methyl B12 (sub-lingual)
3 Responses
Sort by: Helpful Oldest Newest
Avatar universal
By the way, don't be scared by the above post saying you can't get enough D unless you live in the Deep South.  If that were true, the only people alive would be in the sunniest places, but to the contrary, people live everywhere and have for thousands of years without supplementing.  Plains Indians, for example, survived for thousands of years without access to deep water fish and were quite hardy.  Obviously there are sunny days everywhere, so even if it seems there's no D getting in it obviously is a long as you spend time outdoors even in winter.  It's cold in winter, but quite often very sunny.  So, again, people adapt, people survive, so they must have gotten their D somewhere.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
Recent studies caused a lowering of the recommendation for daily Vitamin D from 1000 units a day to 800, because an association was found with certain problems.  Now, these studies that find associations aren't hard and cold facts, but if you're not deficient you certainly don't need that much, and you wouldn't need it for very long.  But medicine isn't factual, it's more based on information and nobody knows if that information is true, sometimes true, never true.  We're now in a period of tremendous collection of information, but it will be a very long time before that information translates into facts.  The other problem is that people are different and have different needs and different abilities to digest and store nutrients.  What's okay for one might be harmful to another.  With so many theories of nutrition out there, we're all essentially experimenting on ourselves.  I wouldn't personally take that much D every day, particularly as D stores in the body as a fat soluble vitamin, but I can't tell you, nor do I believe anyone can tell you, what the ideal amount would be.
Helpful - 0
Avatar universal
vitamin D. It’s important for bone health, hormone
production and protection against cancer.
You get vitamin D from the sun and a few foods — mostly deep sea cold water fatty fish.
Unless you live in the Deep South, it’s impossible to get enough vitamin D from sunlight,
November through February.
Vitamin D and your bones
Vitamin D improves our absorption of calcium and phosphorous, minerals essential for
healthy bones. Low levels of vitamin D result in higher risk of fall and fractures.
Children with low vitamin D develop rickets. This causes bowing of the legs. Adults can
develop a similar condition — osteomalacia — where slight bone softening causes a
gnawing pain often mistaken for fibromyalgia.
Vitamin D and Cancer
Low vitamin D is associated with increase risk of cancers including colon, breast and
prostate. Vitamin D actively inhibits the uncontrolled cell growth typical of cancer in
most tissues of the body.
Adequate Vitamin D reduces risk of Type 2 diabetes and multiple sclerosis. Correcting
vitamin D can reduce blood pressure.
Testing for vitamin D
Make sure your doctor checks your 25-hydroxy vitamin D. Levels below 20 are deficient,
20 - 30 borderline, and 30- 50 healthy. The best month to test? November. If you’re
deficient then, you’ll be severely deficient at the end of winter.
Vitamin D from the sun
10 minutes of direct sun on the face and arms 2 to 3 times a week is adequate, March
through October (year round in the Deep South). Even an SPF 8 sun screen, however,
will block vitamin D production by 90%. So get some direct sun and wear sun screen the
rest of the time.
How much do you take?
Deficient? 50,000 units in a single capsule once a week for eight weeks works well for
most. Then 50,000 units once or twice a month. The usual daily recommended amount is
800 to 1200 units. if you’re usiing 400 unit tablets.
What about toxicity?
Most experts agree 5,000 to 10,000 units a day are safe. Toxicity causes absorption of too
much calcium resulting in kidney stones, kidney failure and calcification of the arteries.
The above recommendation is well within the safe range.
If your D is 73 that is good!!
Helpful - 0
Have an Answer?

You are reading content posted in the Nutrition Community

Top Healthy Living Answerers
Avatar universal
Arlington, VA
Learn About Top Answerers
Didn't find the answer you were looking for?
Ask a question
Popular Resources
14 super-healthy foods that are worth the hype
Small changes make a big impact with these easy ways to cut hundreds of calories a day.
Forget the fountain of youth – try flossing instead! Here are 11 surprising ways to live longer.
From STD tests to mammograms, find out which screening tests you need - and when to get them.
Tips and moves to ease backaches
Here are 12 simple – and fun! – ways to boost your brainpower.