I tend to believe he did molest her. You're husband is hurt because you're not 100% behind him on this. That's manipulative.
Nighthawk... You do not know the daughter is lying. Me for instance told my mom that my step dad had molested me since iIwas about 5 years old. She ccontacted the authorities and when it all got started and they did exams on me after that Itold them iIwas lying bbecause Iddidn'twant my younger siblings to be without a father like I was. I was 13 when i finally told. So trust me Iwwouldn't just "assume" she is lying
I'm not assuming she is lying, i am assuming the father may not be lying as he is willing to go and get a lie detector test. Someone here said that their father was a "serial killer" and that he could lie undetected. I'm not sure of the statistics, but i don't think that a good man never in trouble and completely blown away by this alleged occurrence would be able to lie as easily as a serial killer. Incidentally. I 'm so sorry for the family of the serial killer. That's terrible.
Just to clarify, is your husband a good man? has he been a good father, or have there been problems that have occurred because he has mental problems.? Do you otherwise have a good marriage and you consider him to be a good father? Did he have a record when you met him.?
Alternately, did your daughter get caught in lies as a child? was she somewhat deceitful as a child? Would she have any reason to hate her father enough to break you away from him.?
I am not discounting the abuse others have suffered only telling my truth about my sister who lied many times about sexual abuse, and also had her teenage daughter lie about her step father abusing her. After awhile, the alleged offender went back to live with them both. I only have my experience to share. I respect all experiences given on this forum.
I do consider him a good father, a good man, a good person whom I have never seen do anything mean or malicious to anyone. Yet I have observed that she can be mean and malicious and have watched her be very cruel to other children when young and later to girl friends and then her boyfriends. And she has accused others - friends, room mates, co-workers but not been willing to take action. I understand none of these mean she is lying now. We certainly were not perfect parents, and we had kids young, but we were dedicated to our kids and to providing a healthy happy home - it was our priority. She doesn't seem to hate him like she hates me (she now says because I did not protect her from him). She was always daddy's little girl. I don't discount anyone's abuse either, it's a very real and painful situation for many. Honestly, I previously thought it was always stepdads and never knew it happened with biological fathers, but now have read a lot and that was my own misconception I have angered some people by not just believing my daughter but I have tried to keep an open mind and they are both convincing, obviously complicated by the fact that I love them both very much. All I want is the truth so we can all move forward.
I can't wait to hear how your husband did with the lie detector test.
You can't be a people pleaser, when it comes to displacing the man you married out of high school. You need to be very disciplined about being full apprised of all possibilities, and i think you're doing that well. It's not like you're going to cut your daughter off even if she is lying. Hopefully, when a kid acts out, their parents will be able to catch it, whatever it is , and get them help. But, as i said, the last thing my sister was into, was a diagnosis, but it's like the kid crying wolf at this point. She was simply too dangerous to be part of my life. With a kid it's a bit different.
I'm glad to be able to juxtapose both your husband and daughter's personality traits. I think it speaks volumes and needs to be considered.
When you do talk to your daughter, you have to use it as a teaching moment, and not be shy about being honest as to your evaluation of her personality and how that you also have to take it into consideration.
Your daughter is 16 now, right? so you have time, to talk to her with a psychologist before she's off to college. (hopefully). Our kids grow up so much in college, with some family counseling she may have a chance to grow up a bit with the help of family and a professional. I sure wouldn't suggest that you let this go. Fortunately unless she' inclined to be a runner, she will stay at home and take the heat that comes from the type of accusation, just like your husband is taking the heat. And just like you're taking the heat. The worse thing would be to let it go without talking as you are here, being honest about how you truly feel about he subject. Many parents that deny their child'd allegations of the bat, refuse to discuss it at all. They just make a decision on who's lying and repel the person they feel is guilty either of abuse or character assassination. I think there should be a charge for people that malign other people's characters. In some cases there is, like at work, but many times in families it is so repulsive that everyone other than the accuser,, just wants it to go away. The thing is, you need to open up the communication and talk to her about the way she has been treating people. The fact that maybe you haven't only serves to embolden her actions towards other people,
I don't envy how hard it is for your family right now. But i know that in a family there are often struggles, and as long as everyone opens the lines of communication, there's a possibility of healing and progress in relationships.
Want to know the results, I'm waiting with bated breath. i'm thinking of you often. I guess it brings back so many family memories of my own.hey, I lived through it. Nobody died. The human will prevails.